Difference between revisions of "Team Fortress Wiki:Community topics notability assessment project/Custom map assessments"

From Team Fortress Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
m
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
This page is a record of '''Custom map assessments''' against the Team Fortress Wiki's [[Team_Fortress_Wiki:Community_topics_notability_guidelines#Custom_map_notability|Community topics notability guidelines for custom maps]].
+
{{TFWiki navbar}}
 +
{{hatnote|See [[Team Fortress Wiki:Community topics notability guidelines]].}}
  
−
'''Patched'''/'''added''' : Content that Valve has added to the game through their published patches.
+
This page serves as a comprehensive reference for assessing the notability of '''Custom maps''' on the Team Fortress Wiki. Please read the [[Team Fortress Wiki:Community topics notability guidelines#Custom_map_notability|full guidelines]] for more detailed information.
  
−
* '''Official''' : Valve's term for Patched maps that they developed.
+
'''Glossary''':
−
* '''Community''' : Valve's term for Patched maps they did not develop.
+
: '''Patched''' / '''Added''' : Content added to the game by Valve through updates.
−
* '''Custom''' : This wiki's specific term for maps that the Community developed that Valve has not yet added with their Patches.
+
: '''Official''' : Maps developed by Valve and officially added through updates.
 +
: '''Community''' : Maps created by the community and added via official updates that were not developed by Valve.
 +
: '''Custom''' : Maps created by the community but not yet officially added to the game by Valve.
  
−
'''Notability basis''' : Factors considered {{c|+|for}} and {{c|-|against}} notability.
+
'''Notability criteria''':
 +
: '''Notability basis''': {{c|+|for}} and {{c|-|against}} notability.
 +
: '''Assessment''': The outcome of the assessment with a link to the discussion as needed.
  
−
'''Assessment''' :  Result of assessment with link to discussion as needed
+
== Assessments ==
−
: {{md}}{{c|yes|[[tbdLinkToDiscussion|Notable]]}} {{md}} {{c|no|[[tbdLinkToDiscussion|Not notable]]}} {{md}} {{c|?|[[tbdLinkToDiscussion|Not assessed]]}}
 
  
 
{| class="wikitable grid"  
 
{| class="wikitable grid"  
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | List of Custom Map Notability Assessments
+
! class="header" style="background: #F3A957;" colspan="5" | List of Custom Map Notability Assessments
 
|-<!-- DO NOT MAKE SORTABLE, IF YOU WANT A DIFFERENT ORDERING, SUGGEST AND DISCUSS IT -->
 
|-<!-- DO NOT MAKE SORTABLE, IF YOU WANT A DIFFERENT ORDERING, SUGGEST AND DISCUSS IT -->
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;width: 22%;" | Custom map  
+
! class="header" style="background: #F9D483;width: 22%;" | Custom map  
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;width: 24%;" | Notability basis
+
! class="header" style="background: #F9D483;width: 24%;" | Notability basis
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;width: 14%;" | Assessment  
+
! class="header" style="background: #F9D483;width: 14%;" | Assessment  
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;"            | Notes/Context  
+
! class="header" style="background: #F9D483;"            | Notes / Context  
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with later variants that were added by Valve:  
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with later variants that were added by Valve:  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Bagel]]<br/>[[Fifthcurve]]<br/>[[Maple Ridge]]<br/>[[Millstone]]<br/>[[Moonshine]]<br/>[[Rumble]]<br/>[[Slaughter]]<br/>[[Undergrove]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Bagel]]<br/>[[Fifthcurve]]<br/>[[Maple Ridge]]<br/>[[Millstone]]<br/>[[Moonshine]]<br/>[[Rumble]]<br/>[[Slaughter]]<br/>[[Undergrove]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|+|Has added variant}}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|+|Has added variant}}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |Having an added variant alone is sufficient notability.
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with no known notability (recently created pages, typically 2020-2021).
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with no known notability (recently created pages, typically 2020-2021).
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Conifer]]<br/>[[Free2fort]]<br/>[[Gibson]]<br/>[[Hybrid]]<br/>[[Npire]]<br/>[[Strata]]<br/>[[Zinkenite Valley]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Conifer]]<br/>[[Free2fort]]<br/>[[Gibson]]<br/>[[Hybrid]]<br/>[[Npire]]<br/>[[Strata]]<br/>[[Zinkenite Valley]]
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|-|Unknown notability}}
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|-|No notability}}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" | Recently created pages with no known notability.  
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" | Recently created pages with no known notability.  
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with no stated notability (pages typically created around 2014-2015):  
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps with no stated notability (pages typically created around 2014-2015):  
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Alpen]]<br/>[[Eclipse]]<br/>[[Final Destination 2015]]<br/>[[Wubwubwub]]
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Alpen]]<br/>[[Mesaworks]]<br/>[[Final Destination 2015]]<br/>[[Wubwubwub]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|?|Unknown notability}}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|?|Unknown notability}}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" | 2014-2015 postings with no stated notability. Generally posted and/or maintained by [[User:Dr. Scaphandre|one editor]], but other ranking editors <!-- [[User:TidB|TidB]], [[User:Tark|Tark]], [[User:Darkid|Darkid]] -->are also recorded.
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" | 2014-2015 postings with no stated notability. Generally posted and/or maintained by only one editor, [[User:Dr. Scaphandre|Dr. Scaphandre]], but other ranking editors are also recorded as making edits to these pages (e.g., [[User:TidB|TidB]], [[User:Tark|Tark]], [[User:Darkid|Darkid]] ).
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | "Ancient" custom map pages with no stated notability (except possibly they may be competitive):  
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | "Ancient" custom map pages with no stated notability (except possibly they may be competitive):  
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Antiquity]] <!-- Posted to wiki c-->2011<br/>[[Cashworks]]<br/>[[Convoy]] <!-- Posted to wiki some time before-->2010<br/>[[Cranetop]]<br/>[[Dusk]]<br/>[[Furnace Creek]]<br/>[[Hunted (map)]]<br/>[[Meridian]]<br/>[[Stoneyridge]]
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Antiquity]] <!-- Posted to wiki c-->2011<br/>[[Cashworks]]<br/>[[Convoy]] <!-- Posted to wiki some time before-->2010<br/>[[Cranetop]]<br/>[[Dusk]]<br/>[[Furnace Creek]]<br/>[[Hunted (custom map)]]<br/>[[Meridian]]<br/>[[Stoneyridge]]
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|?|Unknown notability (Legacy)}}
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|+|Cashworks}}<br/>{{c|+|Convoy}}<br/>{{c|-|No evidence of notability for the rest}}
 +
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |Was posted and/or maintained by one or more respected early editors, 2011 or earlier. Some may be Competitive.  
+
* Mostly carried over from [[Team Fortress Wiki|TF2 Wiki]].
 +
* Each was posted and/or maintained by one or more respected early editors, but only to 2011 at the latest.
 +
* Unknown whether any were Competitive.
 +
* Convoy was popular and retains interest and is referenced in discussions of [[Helltrain]].
 +
* Cashworks was added to the game in 2023.
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Historic custom maps with many variants that were widely popular on Community servers or introduced features to the game or Community server activities:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Historic custom maps with many variants that were widely popular on Community servers or introduced features to the game or Community server activities:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Achievement Idle]]<br/>[[Glacier|Glacier (1st snowfall)<br/>(mentioned in Blog)]]<br/>[[Orange X]]<br/>[[Trainsawlaser]]<br/>[[Morrigan Alley]]<br/>[[Trade Plaza]]<br/>[[Minecraft]]<br/>[[Walkway]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Achievement Idle]]<br/>[[Glacier|Glacier (1st snowfall)<br/>(mentioned in Blog)]]<br/>[[Orange X]]<br/>[[Trainsawlaser]]<br/>[[Morrigan Alley]]<br/>[[Trade Plaza]]<br/>[[Minecraft]]<br/>[[Walkway]]
Line 55: Line 64:
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps used for Competitive games:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps used for Competitive games:
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Obscure]]<br/>[[Product (competitive)|Product<br/>(competitive Viaduct)]]<br/>[[Warmfront|Warmfront<br/>(competitive Coldfront)]]
+
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Obscure]]<br/>[[Product (competitive custom map)|Product<br/>(competitive Viaduct)]]<br/>[[Warmfront|Warmfront<br/>(competitive Coldfront)]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|?|Competitive }}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |{{c|?|Competitive }}
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps that have Competitive variants:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps that have Competitive variants:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Coalplant]]<br/>
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Coalplant]]<br/>
Line 69: Line 78:
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps made to demonstrate Community content packs:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps made to demonstrate Community content packs:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Backlot]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Backlot]]
Line 81: Line 90:
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Construction Theme]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Construction Theme]]
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Mapping contest winners:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Mapping contest winners:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Nightfall|Nightfall (1st) (added)]]<br/>[[Panic]]{{md}} [[Solitude]]<br/>[[Highwind|Highwind (4th)]]{{md}} [[Cornfield]]{{md}} [[Scoville]]{{md}} [[Arctic]]{{md}} [[Animus]]{{md}} [[Rollout]]{{md}} [[Rollout]]{{md}} [[Vector]]{{md}} [[Slate]]{{md}} [[Premuda]]{{md}} [[Snowdrift]]{{md}} [[Panamint]]{{md}} [[Bayou]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Nightfall|Nightfall (1st) (added)]]<br/>[[Panic]]{{md}} [[Solitude]]<br/>[[Highwind|Highwind (4th)]]{{md}} [[Cornfield]]{{md}} [[Scoville]]{{md}} [[Arctic]]{{md}} [[Animus]]{{md}} [[Rollout]]{{md}} [[Rollout]]{{md}} [[Vector]]{{md}} [[Slate]]{{md}} [[Premuda]]{{md}} [[Snowdrift]]{{md}} [[Panamint]]{{md}} [[Bayou]]
Line 98: Line 107:
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[(A)Symmetry CP Contest]] 2011<br/>(only 1st and 2nd place covered)
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[(A)Symmetry CP Contest]] 2011<br/>(only 1st and 2nd place covered)
 
|-
 
|-
−
| style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Custom maps from Potato MvM mapping competitions and events:
+
| style="background: #F9D483;" colspan="5" | Custom maps from Potato MvM mapping competitions and events:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Teien]]<br/>[[Airdrop]]<br/>[[Sequoia]]<br/>[[Steep]]
 
| style="border:1px solid #333;" |[[Teien]]<br/>[[Airdrop]]<br/>[[Sequoia]]<br/>[[Steep]]
Line 132: Line 141:
 
: 44 = Not covered   
 
: 44 = Not covered   
 
{| class="wikitable grid"  
 
{| class="wikitable grid"  
−
! class="header" style="background: #0080FF; color: #FFFFFF; border:1px solid #333;" colspan="5" | Measurement of Potato MvM Map Coverage  
+
! class="header" style="background: #F3A957;" colspan="5" | Measurement of Potato MvM Map Coverage  
 
|-
 
|-
 
|
 
|

Latest revision as of 23:02, 2 October 2023

v • d • e
Team Fortress Wiki
Guidelines
Images
Discussion
Languages
Help center
Wiki
Technical
See Team Fortress Wiki:Community topics notability guidelines.

This page serves as a comprehensive reference for assessing the notability of Custom maps on the Team Fortress Wiki. Please read the full guidelines for more detailed information.

Glossary:

Patched / Added : Content added to the game by Valve through updates.
Official : Maps developed by Valve and officially added through updates.
Community : Maps created by the community and added via official updates that were not developed by Valve.
Custom : Maps created by the community but not yet officially added to the game by Valve.

Notability criteria:

Notability basis: Pictogram plus.png For and Pictogram minus.png Against notability.
Assessment: The outcome of the assessment with a link to the discussion as needed.

Assessments

List of Custom Map Notability Assessments
Custom map Notability basis Assessment Notes / Context
Custom maps with later variants that were added by Valve:
Bagel
Fifthcurve
Maple Ridge
Millstone
Moonshine
Rumble
Slaughter
Undergrove 		Pictogram plus.png Has added variant Having an added variant alone is sufficient notability.
Custom maps with no known notability (recently created pages, typically 2020-2021).
Conifer
Free2fort
Gibson
Hybrid
Npire
Strata
Zinkenite Valley 		Pictogram minus.png No notability Recently created pages with no known notability.
Custom maps with no stated notability (pages typically created around 2014-2015):
Alpen
Mesaworks
Final Destination 2015
Wubwubwub 		Pictogram question.png Unknown notability 2014-2015 postings with no stated notability. Generally posted and/or maintained by only one editor, Dr. Scaphandre, but other ranking editors are also recorded as making edits to these pages (e.g., TidB, Tark, Darkid ).
"Ancient" custom map pages with no stated notability (except possibly they may be competitive):
Antiquity 2011
Cashworks
Convoy 2010
Cranetop
Dusk
Furnace Creek
Hunted (custom map)
Meridian
Stoneyridge 		Pictogram plus.png Cashworks
Pictogram plus.png Convoy
Pictogram minus.png No evidence of notability for the rest
  • Mostly carried over from TF2 Wiki.
  • Each was posted and/or maintained by one or more respected early editors, but only to 2011 at the latest.
  • Unknown whether any were Competitive.
  • Convoy was popular and retains interest and is referenced in discussions of Helltrain.
  • Cashworks was added to the game in 2023.
Historic custom maps with many variants that were widely popular on Community servers or introduced features to the game or Community server activities:
Achievement Idle
Glacier (1st snowfall)
(mentioned in Blog)
Orange X
Trainsawlaser
Morrigan Alley
Trade Plaza
Minecraft
Walkway 		Pictogram plus.png Historic
Custom maps used for Competitive games:
Obscure
Product
(competitive Viaduct)
Warmfront
(competitive Coldfront) 		Pictogram question.png Competitive
Custom maps that have Competitive variants:
Coalplant
 Pictogram question.png Has competitive variant
Custom maps made to demonstrate Community content packs:
Backlot Pictogram question.png Content pack Swamp Theme
Atrophy
Hardhat 		Pictogram question.png Content pack Construction Theme
Mapping contest winners:
Nightfall (1st) (added)
Panic ·  Solitude
Highwind (4th) ·  Cornfield ·  Scoville ·  Arctic ·  Animus ·  Rollout ·  Rollout ·  Vector ·  Slate ·  Premuda ·  Snowdrift ·  Panamint ·  Bayou 		Pictogram plus.png Contest winners A/D CTF and Payload Race Contest 2009
Wildfire (1st)
Fusion (3rd)
Stockpile (7th)
Landfall (9th) (Added)
Overlook (10th) 		Pictogram plus.png Contest winners Competitive CTF Contest 2010
Croissant (1st)
Process (2nd) (Added) 		Pictogram plus.png Contest winners (A)Symmetry CP Contest 2011
(only 1st and 2nd place covered)
Custom maps from Potato MvM mapping competitions and events:
Teien
Airdrop
Sequoia
Steep 		Pictogram question.png Contest winners Mappers vs Machines Contest 2017
Dockyard
Waterfront
Downtown
Steep
Teien
Powerplant
Metro 		Pictogram question.png Community events
Pictogram plus.png Contest winners 		Operation Titanium Tank 2017
Reforged 2020
Area 52 ·  Barren ·  Calico ·  Casino City ·  Coastrock ·  Condemned ·  Dockyard ·  Doppler ·  Downtown ·  Giza ·  Hideout ·  Isolation ·  Metro ·  Outlands ·  Oxidize ·  Powerplant ·  Quetzal ·  Radar ·  Sequoia ·  Shiverpeak ·  Skullcove ·  Snowpine ·  Spacepost ·  Steep ·  Teien ·  Trainyard ·  Underground ·  Waterfront ·  Waterlogged ·  Yucatan Pictogram question.png Community events
Pictogram plus.png Contest winners 		Operation Canteen Crasher 2018-2019
Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition?
Area 52 ·  Barren ·  Brugge ·  Casino City ·  Coastrock ·  Cyberia ·  Derelict ·  Dockyard ·  Doppler ·  Downpour ·  Frostwynd ·  Goldpit ·  Hanami ·  Hillside ·  Hideout ·  Hoovy Dam ·  Isolation ·  Kelly ·  Maple Hill ·  Meltdown ·  Metro ·  Oilrig ·  Outlands ·  Oxidize ·  Powerplant ·  Production ·  Quetzal ·  Radar ·  Redstone Ridge ·  Rust Valley ·  Sequoia ·  Shiverpeak ·  Silent Sky ·  Skullcove ·  Snowpine ·  Spacepost ·  Steep ·  Teien ·  Transmission ·  Trainyard ·  Underground ·  Waterfront ·  Waterlogged ·  Winterbridge ·  Wizardry Pictogram question.png Community events
Pictogram plus.png Contest winners 		Operation Madness vs Machines 2019-2020
Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition?
Akure ·  Autumnull ·  Boogge ·  Cliffside ·  Dusk ·  Estate ·  Giza ·  Goldpit ·  Hanami ·  Hideout ·  Hoovy Dam ·  Kelly ·  Production ·  Rust Valley ·  Seabed ·  Sharp ·  Silent Sky ·  Swirl ·  Tensai ·  Transmission ·  Winterbridge ·  Yiresa Pictogram question.png Community events
Pictogram plus.png Contest winners 		Operation Digital Directive 2019-2020
Was there in fact a vetting mapping competition?


62 = Total MvM maps in larger Potato Events
18 = Covered
44 = Not covered
Measurement of Potato MvM Map Coverage
Retrieved from "https://wiki.teamfortress.com/w/index.php?title=Team_Fortress_Wiki:Community_topics_notability_assessment_project/Custom_map_assessments&oldid=3522518"